SCHUFA scoring: When a score can itself be an automated decision
C-634/21 concerns the score’s determining role in subsequent decisions, not an unconditional ban on credit calculations.
Revisión editorial:
El texto de este artículo está disponible en inglés en esta versión del sitio.
Contexto y fuentes
The CJEU held on 7 December 2023 that producing a probability score can fall under Article 22 where a recipient relies strongly on it for a decision. The actual influence in the downstream process matters. The existence and conditions of statutory exceptions still need assessment. [1]
Alcance y límites
A score is not unlawful merely because it exists. Its use and applicable basis are relevant.
Explicación sencilla
A recommendation is not merely optional if it effectively determines all later decisions. Actual influence matters more than its label.
Recomendaciones prácticas
We recommend documenting how external scores affect decisions and when staff can depart from them. Assess whether reviewers can understand relevant information. Individuals can collect available disclosures and refusal explanations. Do not assume that a signature or a separate contracting organisation automatically removes the automation issue.