CJEU C-300/21: No seriousness threshold, but damage is still required
The Österreichische Post judgment distinguishes infringement, damage and causation. Minor damage is different from no damage.
Revisão editorial:
O texto deste artigo está disponível em inglês nesta versão do site.
Contexto e fontes
On 4 May 2023, the CJEU explained that Article 82 GDPR requires infringement, material or non-material damage and a causal link. An infringement alone is insufficient, while non-material damage cannot be subject to an additional seriousness threshold. Establishing and assessing damage remains case-specific. [1]
Âmbito e limites
The judgment provides no fixed payment per data category and does not turn every expression of dissatisfaction into proven damage.
Explicação simples
Three questions remain: what was unlawful, what harm occurred and how are they connected? Answering the first does not answer the others.
Recomendações práticas
We recommend organising evidence under these questions. Describe actual events and effects instead of copying generic statements. Organisations should address complaints using the same distinctions. Provide an adviser with incident information and personal observations; the judgment is an interpretation, not a guaranteed outcome for a particular dispute.