← Retour au blog
Arrêts majeursÉlevéeÀ la une

BGH on loss of control: When a data breach can cause non-material damage

VI ZR 10/24 recognises possible damage from loss of control, not automatic compensation or a fixed tariff.

Révision éditoriale :

Le texte de cet article est disponible en anglais dans cette version du site.

Contexte et sources

On 18 November 2024, the BGH held in VI ZR 10/24 that even short-lived loss of control over personal data can constitute non-material damage without additional proven misuse. The remaining conditions of a claim still matter. The discussed scale of €100 is not a universal statutory tariff. [1]

Portée et limites

A GDPR infringement alone does not automatically result in payment. Damage, causation and amount require case-specific assessment.

En termes simples

Losing control of personal information can matter without later financial theft. That does not make every unwanted processing event worth the same amount.

Recommandations pratiques

We recommend preserving incident notices and recording confirmed effects without turning assumptions into facts. Organisations should determine disclosure scope carefully and communicate clearly. Assess a claim using the actual documents and legal conditions rather than relying on a general compensation calculator.

Source primaire / référence

  1. [1] BGH (18.11.2024), VI ZR 10/24: Kontrollverlust