← Torna al blog
Sentenze chiaveAlta

BGH XI ZR 107/22: Proving payment authorisation

The March 2024 judgment concerns burden of proof under historical payment law, not a universal ruling on phishing negligence.

Revisione editoriale:

In questa versione del sito il testo dell’articolo è disponibile in inglese.

Contesto e fonti

The BGH’s judgment of 5 March 2024 assigns proof of authorisation to the payment provider in the historical statutory setting addressed. [1] Current sections 675u and 675w BGB distinguish reimbursement and proof: recording use and authentication of an instrument does not necessarily establish the payer’s authorisation. [2], [3]

Ambito e limiti

A phishing assessment requires the actual events and applicable provisions. Reimbursement and possible counterclaims need separate examination.

Spiegato in modo semplice

A technically used key does not conclusively identify who authorised a particular transaction. Logging in and consenting to payment are different questions.

Raccomandazioni pratiche

We recommend promptly contacting the bank through a trusted route, preserving messages and approval screens, and recording what you did and did not confirm. Do not prematurely delete evidence. Timing, displayed purpose and actual procedure matter more than claims that either banks or customers always bear fraud losses.

Fonte primaria / riferimento

  1. [1] BGH (05.03.2024), XI ZR 107/22: Authorisation and burden of proof
  2. [2] § 675u BGB: Nicht autorisierte Zahlungsvorgänge
  3. [3] § 675w BGB: Nachweis der Authentifizierung